[suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post Reply
josna238
Posts: 182
Joined: Sun Feb 05, 2017 4:09 pm

[suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by josna238 »

Is not about aesthetical preferences, is because, in my opinion, it is very similar to flashbang button. In fact I have throw smoke to aliens more than once on rendezvous missions where some rebels have smoke and other flash on their pockets randomly...
Clibanarius
Posts: 205
Joined: Sun Feb 05, 2017 1:33 am

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by Clibanarius »

I don't have the slightest bit of difficulty in differentiating between the frag, smoke, and flashbang icons at a glance.
nightwyrm
Posts: 260
Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2017 4:52 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by nightwyrm »

I have made the same mistake as well, especially during rendezvous and mini-retal missions where the rebel just have random stuff. Frag is easy to distinguish from the other two but I often have to take a second look at flash/smoke just to make sure I got the right one. Heck, even Xavier made the flash/smoke mistake in one of his vids.
LordYanaek
Posts: 940
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 1:34 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by LordYanaek »

On Rendezvous it's easy, the rebels with smoke grenades have SMG line weapons. Assault Rifles and Shotgun have flashbangs. It doesn't make a lot of sense as SMG gives mobility and would be better for flashbang but it seems like it's always the same setup.
User avatar
3tamatulg
Posts: 41
Joined: Sat Feb 04, 2017 1:56 am

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by 3tamatulg »

I make tons of mistakes.

I have never in over 200 hours of LW2 made this mistake.
chrisb
Pavonis Dev
Posts: 364
Joined: Mon Feb 27, 2017 8:43 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by chrisb »

Even if the icons are somewhat similar, pressing it does not throw the grenade. You have to pick a spot before it gets thrown. During that time the bottom of the screen says in big letters "Launch Smoke Grenade" or "Launch Flashbang Grenade".

I don't support changing the icon, I think people are used to what it looks like and this is remedied by paying attention to your actions. Tactical battles are often won or lost based on mistakes like this, take your time, pay attention to what your doing, there is no turn time limit.
oesis
Posts: 38
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 11:36 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by oesis »

I have made the same mistake several times. Especially when I was starting, I would confuse the 2 all the time. Probably happened the most on faceless missions, where you have rebels with one or the other. Though I think I got used to checking because I don't make the mistake very often anymore. Overall making them look a tad more different couldn't hurt.
Zyrrashijn
Posts: 188
Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2016 6:02 am

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by Zyrrashijn »

I've seen Xwynns throw Smoke at the enemy without so much noticing. Was hilarious. But i don't think this has to be redesigned in any way.
josna238
Posts: 182
Joined: Sun Feb 05, 2017 4:09 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by josna238 »

chrisb wrote:Even if the icons are somewhat similar, pressing it does not throw the grenade. You have to pick a spot before it gets thrown. During that time the bottom of the screen says in big letters "Launch Smoke Grenade" or "Launch Flashbang Grenade".

I don't support changing the icon, I think people are used to what it looks like and this is remedied by paying attention to your actions. Tactical battles are often won or lost based on mistakes like this, take your time, pay attention to what your doing, there is no turn time limit.
I totally agree with your opinion. Throw smoke to aliens is only my fault. But I also felt that couldn't be the only one. In my case is because I tend to not use smoke at all (if it isn't free). So after several missions spaming flashbangs, I do it almost automatically without reading. That added to the point that the icons are not very different, that they are on the same slot and the number that cover half icon... When a rebel brought a smoke without my permission I just go in my "auto-flashbang mode".

In addition I must say that more than once I also spent 3 minutes planning a groupal tactic and forgot that OW alien I saw at first and thought "keep in mind that OW".
LordYanaek wrote:On Rendezvous it's easy, the rebels with smoke grenades have SMG line weapons. Assault Rifles and Shotgun have flashbangs. It doesn't make a lot of sense as SMG gives mobility and would be better for flashbang but it seems like it's always the same setup.
Thanks for the info I didn't realized that- I totally agree with you too about the matching weapon-grenade. I see more logic your thought than the current setting.
josna238
Posts: 182
Joined: Sun Feb 05, 2017 4:09 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by josna238 »

I won a free smoke via AWC and put frag, flash and smoke:
flashbang smoke
flashbang smoke
flashbang smoke.jpg (63.59 KiB) Viewed 29148 times
Frag has the ring and the grip but the other two... Do you really see them so different?
darkerevent
Posts: 103
Joined: Sat Mar 04, 2017 12:12 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by darkerevent »

Fwiw, I would support making the icons more distinctive. I have trouble telling at a glance too. I've never thrown smoke onto the aliens, but I have moved a character into position for a flashbang throw thinking that it was a bang, only to find out in the preview that it was a smoke.

In my case the issue isn't with telling them apart when both are in the same character's inventory. It's in telling them apart when the character only has one or the other (e.g. a rebel who spawned with a frag and a bang, versus a rebel who spawned with a frag and a smoke). Mostly this is only an issue in missions with uncontrollable character kits (Rendevous), since if I kitted out the character myself I expect them to have such-and-such item already.
Raven496
Posts: 22
Joined: Sat Jan 28, 2017 11:52 am

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by Raven496 »

To the OP...YES they look glaringly similar...would be nice to have smoke grenade icon...of smoke...
chrisb
Pavonis Dev
Posts: 364
Joined: Mon Feb 27, 2017 8:43 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by chrisb »

Raven496 wrote:To the OP...YES they look glaringly similar...would be nice to have smoke grenade icon...of smoke...
I believe this is what the icon looked like in LW1, so that could be used.
LordYanaek
Posts: 940
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 1:34 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by LordYanaek »

This was the LW1 (probably stock XCom EW) smoke grenade icon Image
It's actually used for dense smoke in LW2 Image
So it would require something else.
LW1 dense smoke looked like this : Image

Quick and Dirty attempt at merging the existing icon and the old (now Dense Smoke) icon
SmokeGrenadeMix.png
SmokeGrenadeMix.png (4.82 KiB) Viewed 29090 times
darkerevent
Posts: 103
Joined: Sat Mar 04, 2017 12:12 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by darkerevent »

LordYanaek wrote:Quick and Dirty attempt at merging the existing icon and the old (now Dense Smoke) icon SmokeGrenadeMix.png
I really like that merge. :) If the notion isn't picked up and used officially, perhaps someone can make a modmod that tweaks that.
LordYanaek
Posts: 940
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 1:34 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by LordYanaek »

That would certainly be possible but i really have no experience in modding XCom2 apart from simple ini edits.
I could have a look at the icons if someone can tell me how to get the original files rather than some jpg out of UFOpedia and see if i can get better results by spending more than 3 minutes on it but i don't know how to repack those.

Maybe there are some "Modding XCom2 for dummies" tutorials somewhere :lol:
Rikokrates
Posts: 42
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 4:00 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by Rikokrates »

I actually did this for the first time yesterday, though tbf it was my own fault for rushing and not double checking what my rebels were carrying. I like this:
LordYanaek wrote:This was the LW1 (probably stock XCom EW) smoke grenade icon Image
It's actually used for dense smoke in LW2 Image
So it would require something else.
LW1 dense smoke looked like this : Image

Quick and Dirty attempt at merging the existing icon and the old (now Dense Smoke) icon
SmokeGrenadeMix.png
But maybe it's not possible, maybe the smoke grenade or flash bang icon could have a different colour, similar to hacking objectives when they are yellow.
LordYanaek
Posts: 940
Joined: Mon Jan 23, 2017 1:34 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by LordYanaek »

Changing color isn't a good idea because they have a specific meaning in LW2
  • Green is free
  • White cost one action, doesn't end turn
  • Blueish cost one action, ends turn
  • Yellow cost two actions
  • Gold is main objective action
There are occasional errors in the color-coding (SPARK bombard being green) but once those are fixed it's a very useful feature.
Steve-O
Posts: 124
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2017 8:00 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by Steve-O »

josna238 wrote: flashbang smoke.jpg

Frag has the ring and the grip but the other two... Do you really see them so different?
I can understand why you find them similar, but I personally don't have a problem telling those two apart. Flashbang has a little ring on top, Smoke has no ring and a grip on one side.
roberdjp
Posts: 18
Joined: Tue Jan 17, 2017 4:24 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by roberdjp »

The backgrounds are different. The flashbang has a big flash and the smoke has a cloud of smoke....

It's not the most contrasty treatment in the world, but I have never had an issue telling them apart.
nightwyrm
Posts: 260
Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2017 4:52 pm

Re: [suggestion] Change dessign of the smoke grenade.

Post by nightwyrm »

I think how easy it is to distinguish depends a fair bit on how big your monitor is. I use a 17" laptop to play, so not the biggest screen.
Post Reply